Discover how Manchester United vs Newcastle United stacks up in EAFC 25. Explore their strengths and weaknesses.

Manchester United and Newcastle United are set to clash at Old Trafford in an exciting Premier League showdown. This isn’t just a battle for points, it’s about bragging rights as well. Fans love comparing these two powerhouses, both in real life and in EAFC 25. Manchester United, with stars like Bruno Fernandes, dominates the headlines.
Meanwhile, Newcastle United’s Alexander Isak and Bruno Guimarães have been stealing the show recently. In EAFC 25, the rivalry is just as intense as on the pitch. With contrasting playstyles and player strengths, picking a favorite isn’t easy. Their head-to-head history favors United, but Newcastle’s rise adds spice to the mix. Whether you favor pace or precision, this digital rivalry promises fireworks, just like their upcoming match.
Man United vs Newcastle in EAFC 25
Let’s start with the best possible lineups for both Manchester United and Newcastle United in EA Sports FC 25. These squads showcase each team’s standout players and highlight their strengths on the virtual pitch.
Manchester United’s Best Lineup
Back at home for the final time in 2024 🏠#MUFC || #PL pic.twitter.com/pMXAG2A10p
— Manchester United (@ManUtd) December 28, 2024
- GK: André Onana (83 OVR)
- RB: Diogo Dalot (82 OVR)
- CB: Lisandro Martínez (84 OVR)
- CB: Matthijs de Ligt (84 OVR)
- LB: Luke Shaw (82 OVR)
- CDM: Casemiro (84 OVR)
- CM: Bruno Fernandes (87 OVR)
- CM: Mason Mount (78 OVR)
- RW: Antony (77 OVR)
- ST: Rasmus Højlund (78 OVR)
- LW: Marcus Rashford (81 OVR)
Newcastle United’s Best Lineup

- GK: Nick Pope (83 OVR)
- RB: Kieran Trippier (83 OVR)
- CB: Sven Botman (82 OVR)
- CB: Fabian Schär (82 OVR)
- LB: Dan Burn (78 OVR)
- CDM: Bruno Guimarães (85 OVR)
- CM: Sandro Tonali (85 OVR)
- CM: Joelinton (82 OVR)
- RW: Miguel Almirón (78 OVR)
- ST: Alexander Isak (85 OVR)
- LW: Anthony Gordon (82 OVR)
Head-to-Head Record
In real-life matchups, Manchester United has dominated historically, with:
- 35 wins.
- 10 losses.
- 13 draws across 58 matches.
However, recent encounters show Newcastle catching up. They’ve won three of the last six meetings, including key victories in the Premier League and EFL Cup. Their resurgence adds a fresh twist to this rivalry.
Who’s Better in EA Sports FC 25?
Let's go again! 💪 pic.twitter.com/5rppldB7Rw
— Newcastle United (@NUFC) December 29, 2024
It’s a close call, but Newcastle United edges out Manchester United in EAFC 25. Here’s why:
- Balanced Roster: Newcastle’s squad is well-rounded, with strong attackers (Isak and Gordon), solid midfielders (Guimarães and Tonali), and reliable defenders.
- Playstyle Versatility: Newcastle’s pacey attack and physical midfield make them adaptable for various strategies, from counters to possession play.
- Recent Form: Newcastle’s rise in real-life football translates well into the game, with their players’ stats aligning perfectly for the current meta.
Manchester United still holds appeal, especially for players who prioritize defensive setups and midfield creativity. Bruno Fernandes and Rashford can turn matches around, but the lack of a top-tier striker gives Newcastle the edge.
In EA Sports FC 25, Newcastle United’s combination of pace, power, and balance makes them slightly better for most players. If you love high-energy football, they’re the team to pick!
Looking For More?
Thank you for reading the article. We provide the latest news and create guides for Baldur’s Gate 3, Starfield, ARK Survival Ascended, and more. Also, watch Deltia play games on Twitch or visit his YouTube channel!