Facebook
Reddit
Email
The question of who is the traitor in Black Clover is not a weird one for a Shonen show. This article answers that.
The traitor in the Clover Kingdom in Black Clover was the captain of the Golden Dawn, William Vangeance. A lot of people felt he was a strong, wise leader but was secretly in contact with Patri, the head of the Eye of the Midnight Sun. William was not a traitor in the common sense of the word, as he did not betray the kingdom out of malice. Instead, he was torn between his loyalty to the kingdom and his tie to Patri.
His role in the Elf Reincarnation Arc changed the story forever. His decisions had monumental repercussions, impacting his squad and the whole kingdom. This article examines William’s role, why he made the choices he did, how they shaped the kingdom, and how he tried to atone for his mistakes.
William Vangeance: The Man Behind the Mask
William Vangeance always had an aura of mystery around him. Despite commanding the kingdom’s elite Golden Dawn Magic Knight squad and earning the Wizard King Julius Novachrono’s admiration, he remained an enigma. His mask was initially dismissed as mere concealment for facial scars that symbolized a fractured identity.
What made William unique was not just his World Tree Magic or leadership skills. Unknown to almost everyone, William shared his body with Patri, an elf spirit burning with revenge against the humans who massacred his people centuries ago. Because of this, William was constantly struggling with his loyalties. On one side, he admired Julius and wanted to protect the Clover Kingdom. On the other, he understood Patri’s pain and believed his cause had some truth to it.
This inner conflict led William to allow Patri to carry out his plans instead of stopping him. This was not possession in the usual sense. William never lost consciousness and was aware of Patri’s actions but did not want them to stop. His actions were not motivated by hatred; rather, he was an emotionally conflicted character, and thus, the betrayal was more sorrowful than evil. This inaction made William the traitor in Black Clover.
The Elf Reincarnation Arc: A Turning Point
The Elf Reincarnation Arc was when the traitor’s identity became clear. Patri, using William’s body at times, managed to activate the Reincarnation Spell, bringing back the spirits of dead elves. These elves took over the bodies of some Magic Knights and attacked humans, believing they were getting revenge for what had happened in the past. Overnight, trusted Magic Knights became vengeful enemies, turning comrade against comrade in bloody combat.
While William did not personally harm anyone, his inaction enabled catastrophe. By allowing Patri free rein, he effectively abandoned his duty as captain, leaving his subordinates vulnerable. His actions hurt many people, especially his squad, the Golden Dawn, who suffered huge losses. This moment in the story makes it clear how dangerous his choices were. It also made people wonder if he could ever be trusted again.
The Role of the Traitor in the Story
William’s betrayal transformed Black Clover from a simple adventure into a complex moral drama. By connecting the respected captain of the Golden Dawn to Patri, the series created a conflict that transcended typical good-versus-evil narratives. His actions were not villainous but catastrophic. It taught a painful lesson in how indecision can cause as much damage as malice.
Unlike traditional traitors who scheme against their kingdoms, William genuinely loved the Clover Kingdom. His tragedy lay in his divided heart, torn between loyalty to Julius and empathy for Patri’s suffering. This internal struggle added emotional weight to the story, and he made William one of anime’s most psychologically conflicted antagonists.
His betrayal sends shockwaves throughout the series, setting off some of its most epic fights and pushing characters such as Asta and Yuno to develop beyond their limits quickly. In a sense, William’s defeat was good for the kingdom. There needed to be something to dispel the complacency of people in the Clover Kingdom who were caught up in themselves, unprepared for the greater threats that were beginning to take shape beyond those borders. The trial of the elf war forged more resilient Magic Knights and built bridges between the human nations.
Motivations Behind the Betrayal
What separates William from typical traitors is his motivation. Most betray for power, money, or ideology. William betrayed the Clover Kingdom because he cared too much. His past helps explain why he acted the way he did.
William, as a boy, was cruelly discriminated against for his facial scar — a mark that led others to believe he was cursed. Only two people truly accepted him: Julius, who recognized his potential as a Magic Knight, and Patri, who understood his pain. Because of this, he felt deeply connected to Patri and didn’t want to betray him. This created William’s impossible dilemma.
William believed both sides had legitimate grievances. Humans had massacred the elves centuries ago, while the elves now threatened innocent humans who had no part in that ancient crime. Caught between these truths, William chose passivity, a choice that proved devastating.
His fatal error was believing that by not choosing, he could avoid betrayal. Instead, his inaction made him a traitor in Black Clover, enabling violence against the very kingdom he had sworn to protect.
The Impact on the Golden Dawn and the Clover Kingdom
William’s betrayal had long-lasting effects on the Golden Dawn and the entire Clover Kingdom. His squad, once the best in the kingdom, suffered greatly. Most of its members were seriously hurt or killed when the elves occupied their bodies. That squad, once synonymous with strength, was in shambles and needed rebuilding.
The whole Clover Kingdom also faced a crisis because of the war. The battle against the elves drained resources, and trust in the Magic Knights was damaged. Even though William never directly harmed his comrades, people questioned his leadership. Despite this, some members of the Golden Dawn, like Yuno, still believed in him. Over time, William worked hard to fix the squad and earn back the trust of his allies. His journey of making up for his mistakes became an important part of the story.
William’s Redemption and Legacy
The aftermath of the elf crisis left the Golden Dawn shattered. Once the kingdom’s most prestigious squad, they lost numerous members and their reputation. The entire Magic Knight organization faced public mistrust, with many questioning how they had failed to spot the traitor among them.
Unlike most traitors who die or become permanent villains, William chose a harder path: atonement. When the dust settled, William did not flee or make excuses. He acknowledged his shortcomings and took on the weight of rebuilding. William knew that trust could not be restored overnight, but he was determined to win it back bit by bit. He devoted himself to reforming Golden Dawn, recruiting new members, and reconnecting with its victims.
William’s redemption reached its peak during later crises. When new threats emerged from the Spade Kingdom, he fought on the front lines, using his World Tree Magic not for destruction but to heal and protect. And while he could never change the past, he devoted himself to protecting the Clover Kingdom.
Many who had condemned him began to reassess their judgment. His actions showed that people are not defined by their mistakes but by how they make up for them.
Conclusion
The question of who the traitor in Black Clover has a direct answer but is wrapped in a lot of sadness. William Vangeance’s story elevates Black Clover above simpler battle anime. His betrayal forces viewers to question easy judgments about loyalty and redemption.
Was William truly a traitor if he never actively worked against the kingdom? Does passive enabling count as a betrayal? Can someone serve two masters with conflicting aims, or must we eventually choose? These questions have no simple answers.
What makes William’s story resonant is how recognizably human it is. Most of us will never command magical squads, but many know the agony of divided loyalties—between family and career, personal happiness and duty, or competing values that seem equally important.
His story stands as one of anime’s most nuanced explorations of betrayal, responsibility, and the long road to redemption.
Looking For More?
Thank you for reading the article. We provide the latest news and create guides for Baldur’s Gate 3, Starfield, ARK Survival Ascended, and more. Also, watch Deltia play games on Twitch or visit his YouTube channel!