Facebook
Reddit
Email
Explore the leadership qualities of Gol D. Roger and Whitebeard in One Piece. Who truly deserves the title of the better Leader?
The Captain must inspire trust and loyalty in their crew. They are at the top of the hierarchy and everyone else on their ship must respect and obey their decision. One Piece has excellent examples where a crew works towards achieving their captain’s dream, so it makes the captain of the crew the Leader.
We feel that somewhere Gol D. Roger as an individual was a great pirate, however, he did lack in some places as a leader in comparison to Whitebeard. We are aware that fans have differences in opinion, therefore, let us discuss and compare them as Leaders and understand why we stand with Whitebeard being the better of the two.
Leadership Styles
Gol D. Roger’s presence alone was more than enough to command respect from his crew. He was strong enough to lead his crew to acquire the treasure, One Piece. It was not a simple task because we see the struggle that the new era of pirates is facing to reach it.
The ocean of this universe is unforgiving, and even strong pirates tend to struggle while being on the sail. His excitement and enthusiasm carried the crew towards the treasure. We know he never believed in nurturing them. Rather, he attracted powerful people to join him who share the same vision as he does. His crew worked together as a team, and it felt mechanical.
Meanwhile, Whitebeard has a very different approach. When he got into the position of leadership, he took on the responsibility of giving each of his crew members an assurance that they would be taken care of. He treated them like family and that is what earned the loyalty of the crew.
Unlike Gol D. Roger, he was not behind the treasure of One Piece, nor did he care for power. Whitebeard dedicated his life to protecting his members and called them his “sons.” His crew reciprocated his efforts by respecting him to such a level that they would lay down their lives for him. In this crew, it had warm feelings because each member was given special attention it felt more humane.
Crew Morale and Loyalty in One Piece
Gol D. Roger’s crew was loyal to him out of the obligation of finding the One Piece and making it back. As they all shared the same zest for adventure, it was more like a group of enthusiastic rebel friends. His crew followed him because of his sheer presence and the dream he embodied. Even after his death, the world was sad about his passing away. However, as time passed, they moved on from it.
Shanks and Rayleigh mourned Roger, but they moved on as we know and either chose to have a quiet life or continued with being pirates. The emotional connection was missing, which could be good as this job had danger written in every corner.
Whitebeard’s crew had such strong morale and loyalty towards him that no force could come in between them. When Ace was captured, Whitebeard led an all-out war against the Marines to save him. He was willing to risk everything for just one of his crew members, proving his deep commitment and love for them. His dream was to have a family of his own, and he fulfilled that dream.
Even at his deathbed, he confirmed the existence of One Piece. Here we notice he did not say it to repeat Rogers, but to threaten the World Government that if they continued this, then one day, the power of the treasure would turn the world upside down. Also, his death affected his crew far more than anyone else, to say they were upset is an understatement.
Power and Protection
Both Roger and Whitebeard were two of the strongest men in history, but how they used their power differed. Roger fought to reach the pinnacle of being a Pirate, while Whitebeard fought to protect what he felt was most important. Roger had a small yet elite crew, which meant he lacked in number in comparison to Whitebeard, who commanded an entire fleet.
Whitebeard ensured that his power was not just for himself, he never hesitated to wield it for his family. He used his might to claim territories to keep them safe, ensuring that no one dared to harm those under his protection.
Roger’s leadership style meant that his crew had to be responsible for pushing their weight at all times. Whereas Whitebeard made sure his sons were always protected. This was a major difference between the two: Roger was the leader of a legendary crew, but Whitebeard was not only a fine leader but also a guardian of an empire, even in One Piece.
Influence on the Next Generation
Roger’s influence on the world was undeniable, his last words “You want my treasure? You can have it! I left everything I gathered in one place. Now you just have to find it,” started the Great Pirate Era in One Piece.
His execution was to make sure that the Government sets an example to not follow his path. However, his ambition was so strong that he turned the tables minutes before he died. He inspired countless pirates, including Luffy, to set sail, seek adventure, and not let his vision die. However, Roger did not actively mentor the next generation beyond indirect inspiration.
Whitebeard, on the other hand, personally raised and mentored the next generation of pirates. When he confirmed the existence of One Piece, it was to inspire pirates to fight for injustice. He took in countless orphans and gave them a purpose.
His influence wasn’t just about inspiration—it was about guidance. He protected people like Ace, Oden, and even rival crews like Fish-Man Island. Whitebeard was a leader who shaped the world through direct action rather than just words.
The Legacy They Left Behind in One Piece
After Roger’s death, his crew disbanded. While characters like Silver Rayleigh and Shanks carried on his will, the Roger Pirates ceased to exist. This is because Roger led with strength but centered his leadership around himself. He was the light which his crew followed, without the light they had no reason to stay together.
Whitebeard’s crew, however, remained a family even after his death. Even though they suffered a devastating loss at Marineford, they continued to fight for his ideals. His influence persisted far beyond his lifetime, proving that he was the kind of leader who built something greater than himself.
Conclusion
While Gol D. Roger was a legend and influenced a lot of people in One Piece, Whitebeard was the better leader. Roger’s strength and charisma made him an inspiring figure. Whitebeard’s love, protection, and loyalty made him an unparalleled captain. He created a lasting legacy, ensuring that his crew had a purpose even in his absence.
A great leader not only uplifts and protects others but also leaves behind a strong foundation for them to build upon. In that regard, Whitebeard was the superior leader. We understand both of them had their unique style of leadership and neither of the approaches was wrong. It came down to who was more impactful. If the topic was to compare who was more inspirational, we know Gol D. Rogers would take the spot. One Piece has many captivating characters.
Looking For More?
Thank you for reading the article. We provide the latest news and create guides for Baldur’s Gate 3, Starfield, ARK Survival Ascended, and more. Also, watch Deltia play games on Twitch or visit his YouTube channel!
